Jessica Hardy's Contaminated Supplement Cost Her 4 Olympic Events

Varsity Stack Team8 min read

Jessica Hardy's Contaminated Supplement Cost Her 4 Olympic Events
Short Answer

Swimmer Jessica Hardy made the 2008 U.S. Olympic team in four events, then tested positive for clenbuterol, a banned substance. It came from a supplement that did not list it on the label. Proving that cut her ban to one year, but she still missed the Beijing Games.

Check your supplement in Varsity Stack

Jessica Hardy's case at a glance

QuestionAnswer
What did she test positive for?Clenbuterol, a banned substance, in a sample from July 4, 2008.
Where did it come from?A supplement, AdvoCare Arginine Extreme, that contained it.
Was it on the label?No.
What was the ban?One year, from August 1, 2008 to July 31, 2009.
Did she go to Beijing?No. She withdrew from the U.S. Olympic team.

Jessica Hardy had already made the Olympic team. That is what makes her story so hard to read.

In early July 2008 she swam at the U.S. Olympic Team Trials in Omaha. She qualified for the Beijing Games in four events:

  • The 50 meter freestyle
  • The 100 meter breaststroke
  • The 4x100 meter freestyle relay
  • The 4x100 meter medley relay

Three weeks later she was at home, watching.

What happened four days before her flight?

Hardy was tested three times at the Trials: on July 1, July 4 and July 6. The July 4 sample came back positive for clenbuterol, a banned substance. Her B sample (the second part of the same sample, tested on its own) confirmed it.

She got the news on July 21, at a USA Swimming camp held before the Games. Her flight to Beijing was booked for July 25. Instead of getting on it, she stayed home and withdrew from the U.S. Olympic team.

Hardy said she had never knowingly taken clenbuterol. She turned out to be right, and it took until 2010 to settle it.

Where did the clenbuterol come from?

The case came down to the supplements she had been using. The arbitration panel (the people who heard and decided her case) found that AdvoCare Arginine Extreme contained clenbuterol. She took it before the July 4 test.

Two things about that matter more than the brand name.

First, clenbuterol was not printed on the label. The panel said so plainly, and treated it as a reason to reduce her penalty. Hardy did not skim an ingredient list and miss something. The substance that cost her the summer was never on the list to begin with.

Second, she had been taking the same product for at least eight months. Nothing about it had ever looked wrong.

Did she do what athletes are told to do?

Yes. This was not a mystery powder from a website nobody has heard of. Before she took the supplements, the panel found, Hardy had:

  • Talked to the company directly about how pure its products were.
  • Bought them straight from that company, which she had a contract with, not from an unknown seller.
  • Been told an outside company tested the products for purity, though the company website only backed that up for one product.
  • Asked swimming staff about the products, including the team nutritionist, her coach and the sports psychologist of the USOC (the United States Olympic Committee).
  • Used the same supplements for at least eight months.
  • Seen nothing on the packaging that the panel thought should have worried her.

The panel called all of that "truly exceptional." It said no earlier case it looked at had the same set of facts.

Now look at what a careful athlete could actually do in 2008. Ask the company. Ask your staff. Read the label. Hardy did all three. None of them can tell you what is really inside the product.

Why did proving it not get her to Beijing?

Showing that the supplement was contaminated did not undo the violation.

The panel did not believe Hardy was trying to cheat or to boost her performance. It still found she was careless, because she used a supplement knowing that contamination was a risk. Her situation made that carelessness minor rather than serious, and that let the panel cut the usual penalty.

She was banned for one year, from August 1, 2008 to July 31, 2009.

The World Anti Doping Agency (WADA) appealed and asked for two years. On May 21, 2010 the Court of Arbitration for Sport threw out the appeal and kept the one year.

That is close to the best outcome you can get in an anti doping case. She still missed the 2008 Games. A hearing can prove how a substance got into your body, and it can shorten a ban. It cannot move a competition.

That is the part athletes miss. The real cost is usually not the length of the ban. It is whatever falls inside it:

  • A conference meet
  • An NCAA championship
  • A contract
  • Trials
  • A Games that only comes around every four years

Has anything changed since 2008?

The supplement aisle looks different now. The risk does not.

The NCAA tells athletes this directly:

  • There are no NCAA approved dietary supplements.
  • Vitamins and minerals can still cause a positive drug test.
  • Supplements may contain banned substances that are not listed on the label.
  • Athletes have lost eligibility (the right to compete) after taking supplements.

For a college program, the fueling station is rarely the problem. Every product in it was chosen on purpose. The problem is everything else:

  • A product from the grocery store
  • A new pre workout ordered online
  • Something a teammate swears by
  • A new flavor or a reformulated product
  • A product that showed up through an NIL deal (a deal where an athlete is paid for their name, image and likeness)
  • A supplement someone started over break and never mentioned

So the hard question is not only which ingredients are banned. It is a simpler one. Three months from now, can anyone say exactly which product and which lot an athlete was taking? A lot (or batch) is one production run. For most teams, the answer is no.

What actually lowers the risk?

If you are going to use supplements, independent certification is the strongest tool available. It is the only common way a finished product gets tested by someone other than the company selling it.

Spotting a logo is not the same as checking a product. The United States Anti Doping Agency (USADA) warns that those marks get misused. It says to confirm the exact product in the program's own database, and the lot where a program publishes lots. USADA is also clear that certification lowers risk without erasing it.

That is the honest goal here. Not pretending supplements can be made risk free. Just making an avoidable mistake much harder to make.

How does Varsity Stack help?

Varsity Stack gives athletes and staff one shared process for supplement decisions, and it happens before anyone takes the product.

You scan the exact product you are thinking about to see whether it is certified, and your staff can review it.

A four step supplement review: label review, then certification verification, then staff approval, then athlete use

A program ends up with the record it always wished it had. It shows the exact product, whether it is certified, and what athletes actually take, including what they bought on their own.

What would Varsity Stack not have caught?

It is just as important to say what this would not have done. Varsity Stack does not lab test supplements. In a case like Hardy's, a trace of a banned substance was missing from the label and from any published test data. No app can see inside the product.

What Varsity Stack cuts down is the risk you can see before the first dose: uncertified products, unverified formulas, unchecked purchases and undocumented decisions. It cannot promise a product holds only what its label says.

What did her case leave behind?

Hardy came back. In 2012 she made the Olympic team again. She left London with gold in the 4x100 meter medley relay and bronze in the 4x100 meter freestyle relay.

London did not replace Beijing. The team she had already made was gone.

A supplement does not have to look dangerous to be risky. A banned substance does not have to be on the label to end up in your sample. And proving contamination later does not give you back the meet you missed while everyone sorted it out.

The time to check a product is before the first dose, not after a failed test.

Check your supplement in Varsity Stack

This article is for educational purposes only. Consult a qualified healthcare provider, registered dietitian, or your athletics compliance staff before starting any supplement regimen. For questions about specific governing body rules, consult your athletic compliance officer.

Sources8 sources
  1. usada.orgusada.org
  2. wada-ama.orgwada-ama.org
  3. ncaa.orgncaa.org
  4. nsfsport.comnsfsport.com
  5. sport.wetestyoutrust.comsport.wetestyoutrust.com
  6. bscg.orgbscg.org
  7. usada.orgusada.org
  8. teamusa.comteamusa.com

How we write these

Keep reading

Your stack deserves better intelligence.