A survey of 200 sports supplements bought online in Australia found a banned substance in 35% of them, roughly one in three. None had been independently batch tested. In 57% of the products that tested positive, the substance was not listed on the label.
Check your supplement in Varsity Stack
The survey at a glance
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| What was tested? | 200 sports supplements bought from the Australian online marketplace in 2022. |
| Had they been batch tested? | No. None of the 200 had been independently batch tested. |
| How many held a banned substance? | 35%, roughly one in three. 22 held more than one. |
| Did the label say so? | Not in 57% of the products that tested positive. |
| Which types were riskiest? | Muscle builders (53%), fat burners (49%) and pre workouts (34%). |
You are told to read the label. A survey published in Drug Testing and Analysis is a good reason to stop treating the label as the end of the check.
In 2022 Sport Integrity Australia asked Human and Supplement Testing Australia to buy 200 sports supplements from the Australian online marketplace. The lab tested them against the World Anti Doping Agency (WADA) Prohibited List, the list of substances banned in sport. The results were published in 2025. 35% of the products, roughly one in three, contained at least one banned substance, and 22 contained more than one.
These were ordinary products: protein powders, pre workouts, fat burners and muscle builders, bought online the way you would buy them.
What is the catch in the headline?
None of the 200 had been independently batch tested. A batch is one production run.
That is the whole study, and it is the part that falls off when the headline travels. Naomi Speers, Sport Integrity Australia's research director, put it precisely: more than one in three non batch tested supplements purchased online in Australia contained prohibited substances.
So the finding is not that a third of everything on the shelf is contaminated. It measures what you are exposed to when nobody independent has looked at the product first. That is still most of the market, and still the pile most athletes buy from.
Did the label say what was inside?
Often, no. The more uncomfortable number is not the 35%. It is that 57% of the products that tested positive did not list the banned substance as an ingredient on the packaging or the website.
You could have read every word on that label, known every ingredient, checked each one against a banned list, and still had no way to know. As Speers put it, most of those substances were not even listed on the label.
Sometimes that is contamination (something getting into the product that should not be there) during manufacturing. Sometimes an ingredient is simply left off the label. From your side of the counter, you cannot tell the two apart. Under strict liability, where you are responsible for whatever is in your sample, the result is the same. See how a supplement can make you fail a drug test for what that means under the rules.
Which types of supplements carried the most risk?
The survey found banned substances in:
- 53% of muscle builders
- 49% of fat burners
- 34% of pre workouts
Stimulants (substances that speed up the body) were the most common type found. One more detail cuts against a reflex a lot of athletes have. 83% of the banned substances found were naturally occurring compounds. Only two of the 200 products contained high levels of synthetic stimulants.
The risk here was mostly from plants, not lab chemicals slipped into products. A stimulant taken from a plant is still on the Prohibited List. "Natural", "herbal" and "plant based" tell a tested athlete nothing about whether a product is safe.
What does batch testing change?
Batch testing does not make a supplement risk free, and no credible program claims it does. What it does is put a lab between the factory and you.
Sport Integrity Australia's risk guidance puts batch tested products in a lower risk group than products not specifically tested for banned substances. It also says no supplement is completely safe.
The programs are not the same:
- Informed Sport and NSF Certified for Sport are built for drug tested athletes. Informed Sport tests every finished batch before it goes on sale.
- Informed Choice checks products on sale by buying and testing them at random through the year. That is real quality checking, but it carries no guarantee about the product in your hand.
The NCAA's position lines up with all of it:
- There are no NCAA approved supplements.
- Products can contain banned substances that are not on the label.
- Athletes have lost eligibility (the right to compete) this way.
- Any product should be reviewed with the right athletics staff first.
Certification is evidence, not permission to stop thinking.
What should you ask before a product enters your stack?
Is this exact product certified? Not the brand, not the product line. This one.
Has the batch been tested? A logo says the product line is in a program. The batch number (the code for one production run) says something about the product in your hand.
Is the certification still active? Products leave programs. Logos stay printed on packaging.
What is listed, and what is not? The 57% figure is the reminder: a label cannot tell you what was left off it.
Answer all four before the product becomes part of your routine, not after a question comes up.
Where does Varsity Stack fit?
None of this is news to a sports dietitian. The problem was never that athletes do not know the rule. It is that following it takes five errands, in front of a decision most athletes make in seconds:
- Find the exact product.
- Find the right certification database.
- Match the product against an online record.
- Read the ingredient list.
- Tell somebody on staff what you are taking.
Varsity Stack puts them in one place. Scan a product to see whether it is certified, then add it to your stack, so the staff supporting you can see the real list.
The finding underneath this survey is not that supplements are bad. It is that the packaging does not always tell the truth.
Check your supplement in Varsity Stack
A note on reading the number. The survey examined 200 non batch tested sports supplements purchased through the Australian online marketplace in 2022. It should not be read as a finding that 35% of all dietary supplements worldwide contain prohibited substances. It also says nothing about the rate among products that are independently batch tested.
This article is for educational purposes only. Consult a qualified healthcare provider, registered dietitian, or your athletics compliance staff before starting any supplement regimen. Third party testing reduces risk but cannot guarantee that a supplement is appropriate for a particular athlete or eliminate all risk. For questions about specific governing body rules, consult your athletic compliance officer.



